High Court affirms the registration of in house union – MAYNEU (Maybank Non-Executive Union)

 

MAYNEU, which is the in-house union of Maybank that represents the non-executive employees of the Bank was registered by the Director-General of Trade Union on 3.1.2011.

NUBE (National Union of Bank Employees) aggrieved by the registration, filed a Judicial Review (JR) application on 10.2.2011 to challenge the registration of MAYNEU and obtained an Interim Stay Order against MAYNEU.

NUBE’s application for Judicial Review was heard recently and on 7.11.2013, the High Court delivered its judgment to dismiss NUBE’s JR application. This High Court judgment therefore affirms the legality of the registration of MAYNEU.

It is reported that NUBE would file an appeal to the Court of Appeal over the High Court decision and will also apply for a Stay Order pending the disposal of the appeal.

Malayan Commercial Banks’ Association held its 51st Annual General Meeting

 

Malayan Commercial Banks’ Association (MCBA) held its 51st Annual General Meeting on 11 September 2013 at Renaissance Kuala Lumpur Hotel.

The meeting started off with a formal welcoming address delivered by the President of MCBA, Puan Nora Manaf, who is also the Head of Group Human Capital, Maybank. She commended the EXCO members and other individuals who represented the banks in the Negotiating Teams which amicably concluded the collective agreement for the period 2012-2014 with three separate banking trade unions, namely, ABOM, SBEU Sarawak and SBEU Sabah.

The President also provided a brief on the economic scenarios and the industrial relations landscape affecting the banking industry. She urged member banks to remain focused on economy, nation and society building to ensure that the banking industry delivers the targeted results which are critical for uplifting the national economy under the Economic Transformation Programme or ETP and to continue to ensure bank employees, their families and the communities we belong to grow and prosper.

Puan Nora also reiterated the importance for member banks to strengthen their resolve to cooperate with and support each other and act as a collective in confronting industry-wide industrial relations challenges to bring about an outcome where everyone comes out a winner.

She also took the opportunity to welcome Mr. Samuel Tan of Bank of America Malaysia Berhad, Ms. Nikki Grant-Cook of Citibank Berhad, Puan Nik Ilyanan Mohamed of Deutsche Bank (Malaysia) Berhad and Encik Jamaludin Bakri of RHB Bank Berhad who have been appointed into HR leadership position in their respective Bank.

The Annual General Meeting was well attended by representatives of member banks. Among them were Mr. Cheah Syn Yeam, Head HR of OCBC Bank, Ms. Veronica Lai, Head HR of Royal Bank of Scotland Bhd and Heads of Industrial Relations of member banks.

Banks conclude new CAs with Officers Union & Sabah, Sarawak Bank Employee Unions

Commercial Banks conclude new CAs with Officers Union & Sabah, Sarawak Bank Employee Unions

–          Landmark provisions incorporated into Sarawak Collective Agreement

More than 8,000 members of the Sarawak Bank Employees’ Union (SBEU Sarawak), Sabah Banking Employees’ Union (SBEU Sabah) as well as the Association of Bank Officers (ABOM) can look forward to higher remuneration and better benefits following the recent conclusion of their collective agreements (CA) with their respective Commercial Banks’ Associations. The new CAs will be in effect for the period 2012—2014.

The revised CAs provide an across the board salary adjustment at a minimum 10% (subject to the maximum salary point). This and other agreed terms are by all standards generous. The minimum and maximum basic salaries were also raised by not less than 10%.

The agreements also include a 2 months’ guaranteed contractual bonus except for employees under the collective agreements with ABOM and SBEU Sarawak. These two unions had agreed, since 2009 and 2006 respectively, to incorporate the 2-month contractual bonus into the employees’ basic salary and for the employees thereafter to be paid discretionary bonuses based on the performance of the bank and employee.

In addition, banks will pay a Regional Allowance of 15% to 22.5% of the basic salary for all non-clerical and clerical employees in East Malaysia as part of their monthly wages. In Peninsular Malaysia, banks pay COLA between RM100 to RM150 per month to all clerical and non-clerical employees.

Speaking on the negotiations, the President of the Malayan Commercial Banks Association (MCBA) Nora Abdul Manaf commended the professionalism and constructive engagement demonstrated by the teams from the three unions and the banks, which culminated in the amicable conclusion of the CAs.

“The conclusion of collective agreements reflects the cordial relationship we enjoy which are premised on constructive engagement, mutual respect and reasonableness,” she said.

She said that the wage rates granted under the three CAs were competitive and market leading rates. Employees also enjoy a slew of many other allowances which have been adjusted upward by about 8% to 11%.

With the new agreement, a clerk recruited without prior working experience at entry level is already paid close to the minimum market rate for a basic degree holder without prior working experience as detailed in the MEF Salary Survey for Executives 2012.  In addition, all non-clerical and clerical employees are entitled to claim overtime regardless of their wage levels. The same benefit of overtime entitlement is extended to officers under the collective agreement with ABOM except that the maximum overtime rate is computed at RM2,000 if the officer’s monthly wage exceeds RM2,000.

Nora explained that a notable feature of the new CAs was a landmark provision in the agreement between the Sarawak Commercial Banks’ Association (SCBA Sarawak) and SBEU Sarawak where members had agreed to accept job enlargement and empowerment, in return for a higher salary increase and potentially better bonus.

“The position taken by SBEU Sarawak is highly commended as more often than not, most negotiations for CAs focus merely on wage and benefit increases without the accompanying tangible value-add proposals,” she remarked.

As a result of the above agreement, Nora added, SBEU Sarawak provided a clear platform for banks to further enhance performance and productivity. In return, the earning capacity of the employees was significantly raised besides having the opportunity for employees to further upgrade their skills. Under the collective agreement, these rewards to the employees come in the form of higher salary adjustment, extra annual increment, payment of ex-gratia, revision of minimum retirement age from 55 years to 60 years even before coming into force the Minimum Retirement Age Act.

“The employees covered by the Sarawak collective agreement will enjoy salary increases of 12% to 17%, ranging from RM202 to RM824 extra a month. In addition, performing members have received up to 4.5 months (discretionary) performance bonus based on the performance of the banks and the employee.” remarked the President of SBEU Sarawak, Ms. Hadiah Binti Leen.

There are currently four national banking employees’ trade unions in the country, besides other in-house banking trade unions whose scope of representation is confined only to employees of individual banks.

At the industry level, banking employees in the clerical and non-clerical categories are represented by three national unions, namely National Union of Bank Employees (NUBE), SBEU Sabah and SBEU Sarawak. ABOM is a national union that represents primarily the Class II officers in the executive capacity in Peninsular Malaysia only. Traditionally, new recruits with a diploma and clerks on promotion will be placed in the Class II officer grade.

Banks operating in Peninsular Malaysia, Sabah and Sarawak are represented by MCBA, SCBA Sabah and SCBA Sarawak respectively, which are  registered as trade unions for banking employers under the Trade Union Act.

With these three CAs concluded, the only outstanding CA is with NUBE, which has been referred to the Industrial Court for arbitration.

Picketing by NUBE is misguided and illegal, says MCBA

Malayan Commercial Banks’ Association expresses great concern and disappointment over the announcement by the National Union of Bank Employees (NUBE) that it will air its grievances and exert its demands by picketing at our member bank outlets in Kuala Lumpur on 6.4.2013 (Saturday).

Over the past few months, NUBE had been conducting a series of picketing at several bank offices in various states, with total disregard to its action in causing grave inconvenience to the public and bank customers over issues which could be best resolved only if the Union has chose to raise the issues by using and following through the dispute resolution mechanisms and procedures, as provided both by the collective agreement and the laws of the country.

The Association and our member banks would be ever willing and ready to engage the Union through proper channel and etiquette though admittedly, sometimes member banks do find it insurmountable to satisfy certain union demands, such as demanding for 80 months bonus and demanding for salary adjustment by over 50%.

The Association is equally perturbed by the various allegations, which are riddled with distortions, made against our member banks as reported in the media, despite clarification already provided by member banks at meetings either with the staff concerned, or with the Union, or both.  The Association believes that the distortion was also manifested in the actual membership representation of the Union as stated in the media reports.

As some of the issues which the Union raised have already been referred to the Court for adjudication, the Association is not at liberty to comment on these cases.

It is highly inaccurate and misconceived to even imply that banking employees are being exploited and their welfare, not taken care of. Indeed, the Association takes pride to maintain that banking employees, particularly the non-clerical and clerical staff who come under the scope of representation of NUBE, have always enjoyed  competitive total remuneration and benefits package as compared to other industries.

The Association wishes to highlight that in many of the picketing conducted against its member banks, it was observed that even non-employees of the banks concerned were involved. This is a gross violation of the Industrial Relations Act, 1967. The offence is punishable and on conviction, the offender could be liable to imprisonment or to a fine, or to both. While the Association and its member banks respect the right of unions to conduct industrial actions in accordance of the laws, we would like to advise potential participants to illegal pickets to pay heed to the laws and do not be misled and misguided.

At the same time, the Association urges NUBE to immediately cease such activities which certainly do not help to promote industrial peace and harmony, not to mention the obvious detrimental effect of its disruptive action on the banks, employees and the public at large. We also urge the relevant authorities to intervene and prevent the occurrence of any form of illegal picketing which do not conform to the laws of the country and take the necessary and firm action against those who have flouted the laws.

Statement issued by

Executive Committee of Malayan Commercial Banks’ Association

SCBA Sarawak signs Collective Agreement with SBEU Sarawak

 

Sarawak Commercial Banks’ Association (SCBA) successfully concluded the 13th Collective Agreement with Sarawak Bank Employees’ Union (SBEU) on 28.2.2013. The official signing ceremony was held at Pullman Hotel, Kuching Sarawak on 22 March 2013.

The new Collective Agreement will cover the period from 1.1.2012 to 31.12.2014.

Close to 2,000 employees in the clerical and non-clerical grades who are employed in 13 member banks of SCBA in Sarawak would benefit from this Collective Agreement with a salary adjustment of 10% . In addition, for agreeing to enlarge their job scope, the non-clerical employees would enjoy a further salary adjustment of 3%, whereas the clerical employees will be paid an ex-gratia equivalent to 2% x 12 based on their December salary for 3 years, for period 2012 to 2014. SCBA has also agreed to grant one annual increment for employees who have reached their maximum pay range. Taken together, certain employees may enjoy close to 17% adjustment to their annual basic pay, not to mention the revision in Sarawak Allowance which would take retrospective effect from 1.1.2012.

Rates for other monetary benefits and allowances were also similarly reviewed and where appropriate, adjusted in line with the above increase.

SCBA also agreed to extend the retirement age of employees from 55 years to 60 years, subject to specified medical conditions.

At the signing ceremony, Encik Mohd Daud Abdul Hamid, President, SCBA and Encik Mohammad Azman Bin Abdul Hamid, Secretary, SCBA represented the Association. Puan Hadiah Leen, President, SBEU and Mr. Law Kiat Min, General Secretary, SBEU signed on behalf of the Union.  Puan Nora Manaf, President,  Malayan Commercial Banks’ Association and Encik August Buma, Director of Labor, Sarawak witnessed the signing ceremony. In their respective speech, all commended the negotiating teams for their professional conduct and their ability to come the Collective Agreement amicably. Special mention was made to acknowledge the progressive stand taken by the Union in promoting  and accepting value-add changes which would mutually benefit both the banks and the employees.

Among the Guests-of-Honor who attend this auspicious occasion were Puan Jamilah Putit, Director, Trade Union Department, Sarawak, Heads of HR, namely Puan Nor Rozita Nordin of Affin Bank,  Puan Hamidah Naziadin of CIMB, Mr. Vincent C J Ho of HSBC Bank, Ms. Marlene Goh of Public Bank, Heads of IR of member banks, EXCO members of SCBA and SBEU and a great number of Inter-Relations Committee members from various banks and media personnel.

MCBA signs Collective Agreement with ABOM

 

Malayan Commercial Banks’ Association (MCBA) successfully concluded the collective agreement with the Association of Bank Officers (ABOM). The signing ceremony was held at the Renaissance Hotel in Kuala Lumpur on 18 January 2013.

This is the 11th successive collective agreement signed between the parties for the period 2012-2014.

With the conclusion of the collective agreement, more than five thousand officers employed by 10 member banks of MCBA would receive a salary adjustment at 10% across the board with retrospective effect from 1.1.2012, besides the various enhancements made to other monetary and fringe benefits.

At the signing ceremony, MCBA was represented by its President, Puan Nora Manaf and Executive Director, Mr. YY Lam while ABOM was represented also by its President, Encik Wan Shaharuddin Shah Ismail and General Scretary, Mr. Ng Choo Seong. The Guest-of-Honor, Puan Noor Azian binti Jamaludin, Ketua Penolong Pengarah from the Ministry of Human Resources, witnessed the signing of the MCBA/ABOM collective agreement. The signed collective agreement would be recorded as a Consent Award by the Industrial Court.

Puan Nora Manaf, President of MCBA in her speech, commended the negotiating teams from both the parties for being able to bring the negotiation to an amicable closure within a comparatively shorter time. She also recorded her appreciation to the Union’s General Secretary, Mr. Ng Choo Seong and his negotiating team for consistently demonstrating professional conduct during the negotiation. Among other things, she highlighted that the usefulness of a collective agreement should not be measured solely in terms of how much the workers gain in pay and benefits, or how much the employers can save. The real measure of success is the extent to which the collective agreement has been designed to help improve organization productivity and performance which in turn serves to enhance future earning and proper growth of both the organization and employees. In her closing remarks, she also reminded the parties to remain risk-aware, productive and effective to deal with the challenges ahead in view of the uncertainty in the global economic outlook.

Among the Guests-of-Honor who attended the signing ceremony was Ms. Chuah Mei Lin, Executive Director of the Association of Banks in Malaysia and Mr. Sivagnanam Seenithamy, former Executive Director of MCBA. They were joined by a number of Heads of Human Resources from member banks, including Puan Nor Rozita Nordin, Affin Bank, Nik Ilyana Mohamed,Deutsche Bank, Puan Roselaini Faiz, Hong Leong Bank, other officials from the Ministry of Human Resources, EXCO members from both MCBA and ABOM, together with many human resources practitioners from member banks.

Do union officials have the inherent rights to enter into your premises?

 

On 8.5.2012, NUBE filed a civil suit against Maybank alleging that, the Bank had breached its contractual obligations under the Collective Agreement between MCBA and NUBE. NUBE had applied for an injunction against the Bank to allow them to enter and use the bank premises to hold meeting with their members during office hours, to grant their members paid trade union leave and to notify NUBE prior to ceasing deductions of NUBE subscriptions. The Union also sought an order from the Court to restrain Maybank from granting paid trade union leave to Mayneu ( referring to the Maybank in-house union for non-executives) members, deducting Mayneu’s monthly subscription from salaries and from granting any form of support whether by financial or otherwise. NUBE’s application for an injunction against Maybank was fixed for hearing at the High Court. Subsequently, NUBE filed an application for discovery of documents.

In response, Maybank filed an application to strike out NUBE’s suit on 8.6.2012.

On 7.12.2012, the High Court ruled in favour of Maybank and struck out NUBE’s suit with cost.

NUBE has filed an appeal to the Court of Appeal.

MCBA website enhanced!!

 

We are pleased to inform that some features in the MCBA website have been enhanced to improve reader-friendliness and operational efficiency. For example, member banks can now mass register or create their selected employees to access the website (Members’ Area). If you are the Master User or User accorded with special role/access to some f the functionalities provided by the website, we invite you to explore the differences…

National Wages Consultative Council Method of Implementation Minimum Wage Order 2012

Please be guided by the circular issued by MEF on the above matter. The relevant contents of MEF’s circular are reproduced below as follows:

” The Minimum Wages Order 2012 will come into operation on 1 January 2013 for employer who employs more than 5 employees and regardless of the number of employee employed, an employer who carries out a professional activity classified under Malaysia Standard Classification of Occupations (MASCO). The Order will come into operation on 1 July 2013 for an employer who employs 5 employees or less other than an employer carrying out professional activity classified under MASCO.

2.        In this connection, the National Wages Consultative Council (NWCC) has just issued Guidelines on the Implementation of the National Minimum Wages Order 2012 (in Bahasa Malaysia). Attached is the translated version of the Guidelines in English. Please be informed that the translation of the Guidelines to English is done by MEF and not officially translated by NWCC. The original version in Bahasa Malaysia can be downloaded from the Ministry of Human Resources website i.e. http://www.mohr.gov.my.

3.        Members are advised to go through these Guidelines to enable them to implement the National Minimum Wages before the Order come into operation. ”

Attachment: NWCC_Guidelines